Human and Animal Relationships: A Evolutionary Worldview or Biblical Worldview

Sep 23, 2019 | Article, Creation

This is a guest contribution made by my good friend and co-laborer for the Lord, Pat Mingarelli.


Did you ever wonder why we own pets? Or why do we care about environmental and wildlife causes? And why do so many want to chip in and care for the environment or rescue wild animals? quotes ethologist Marc Bekoff saying, “People have a deep-seated need to connect to nature”. But why?

In some ways it makes sense for atheists to care for the earth and its animals. If you think that this world is all we have you may feel a strong compulsion to take care of it. And if someone thinks that animals are one’s distant kin, one might want to lend them a hand in their survival. But in contrast to that, most animals essentially compete with you and I for the limited space on the planet. So why would we want to care for them?

So what worldview better fits our desire to manage and care for animals and have a relationship with them? Does a biblical worldview or an evolution worldview better explain this?

And why do I even ponder such a topic?

My Love for Animals

Beginning in childhood, I found myself drawn to animals and nature. I had begged my parents for a dog until they finally got me one.  Back then there were no Animal Planet programs, so I remember watching with great intensity Mutual of Omaha’s Wild Kingdom, National Geographic specials and The Under Sea World of Jacques Cousteau (I know I’m dating myself).

As an adult, the wild world still fascinates me physically and spiritually. Nature calls my heart to worship. This is true whether I’m in the great outdoors or simply looking at photos of God’s creation.

Drawn to Nature

One Sunday morning during worship at church, I thought to look at nature photos. I pulled out my phone and began looking at the photos on my Visual Bible Verse of the Day app.  The photos stirred a deeper sense of worship in my heart. I praised God for being such a great Creator.

A photo of a swift fox that I took captured my attention more than the others. I found myself starring into its eyes and felt drawn to it. Something about this animal called to me. I wanted it. Why?

Did I simply admire its design? Did its beauty intrigue me (and why is it beautiful at all, but that’s another blog post)? Or did it just remind me of my dog?  If it did remind me of my dog, that leads us back to my original questions, “Why do we own pets?” and “Why do we desire to care for animals?”

All this then leads us to a more significant question. Does the owning of pets and caring for wildlife point to a biblical worldview or an evolutionary worldview.

Animal Care and an Evolutionary Worldview

Evolution or the philosophy of Scientific Naturalism tell us that human beings came to be through random chance and survival of the fittest. So if survival of the fittest is what brought us here, when did we decide to abandon it and help our less fit animal neighbors?

I do understand that mankind benefits in both direct and indirect ways from raising animals. Animals help us carry out different tasks, which was especially true before the modern age. But saving a species of wildcat or penguin doesn’t really have an obvious benefit to the average person.

For some reason we desire relationship with animals and want to care for them. Evolutionists also tell us that this desire to connect with other species is uniquely human. Pennsylvania State University biological anthropologist Pat Shipman says, “Establishing an intimate connection to other animals is unique and universal to our species,”

When it comes to pets in our modern world, most steal resources from us without giving much back. Sure, many point to companionship, but it some ways pets rob us from companionship with our own species. Would it not be more beneficial to have companionship with one’s own species rather than another?

An evolutionary answer for this on says, “Humans have some powerful circuitry that makes us want to nurture.” Well, if we have this strong desire to nurture, why are so many forgoing children and replacing those children with pets. How does that help our species survive? And how does raising the young of another species in place of one’s own species fit into “survival of the fittest”?

Animal Care and a Biblical Worldview

The biblical worldview postulates a better answer. Two passages in Genesis may provide the reason why humans have an in-dwelt desire to manage and care for nature.

Genesis 1:26 says, “Then God said, ‘Let Us make man in Our image, according to Our likeness; and let them rule over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the sky and over the cattle and over all the earth, and over every creeping thing that creeps on the earth.’ (NASB)” Scholars may disagree on the details of what this means, but what is clear is that God made mankind stewards or rulers over the animal kingdom.

Now the fall of mankind has tainted our control over animals. As John Calvin mentioned in his commentary on Psalm 104, the fall “has deprived men of their dominion over the wild beasts.”

But even though we no longer have full control over the animals, Calvin saw man’s dominion as not completely abolished. And since our dominion is not completely abolished we still desire to manage and care for animals. God gave this as an original command to Adam and surely it is part of our inner self.

In Genesis 2:18-20 says, Then the LORD God said, ‘It is not good for the man to be alone; I will make him a helper suitable for him.’ Out of the ground the LORD God formed every beast of the field and every bird of the sky, and brought them to the man to see what he would call them; and whatever the man called a living creature, that was its name. The man gave names to all the cattle, and to the birds of the sky, and to every beast of the field, but for Adam there was not found a helper suitable for him. (NASB)   

We see in this passage that God did not like the fact that Adam was alone and that he did not have a helper suitable. As a result, God brought the animals he previously made to Adam.

Adam and Animals

Why did God bring the animals to Adam? Does it not seem logical that He brought the animals to Adam for relationship and companionship? So, if God created the animals to be a companion to people, then it would make sense that we would desire companionship with them today.

After this, God no longer address Adams “alone” problem. This implies that God solved Adam’s alone problem with the animals. The Scripture leaves that problem behind when it says, “But for Adam there was not found a helper suitable for him.”

As Ken Ham and Steven Golden write on, “God could have stopped there in His provision of a companion for Adam.”

So Adam had companions, but he still lacked a suitable helper. Only a woman could fill that role. Women are the only suitable help mate match for men, but animals can certainly provide companionship. I believe that was part of their original purpose and still is today.

So, if women are the only suitable match for men, did God make a mistake by bringing Adam the animals? No! Obviously not, since God is infallible and he makes no mistakes. And it seems that one reason God made animals is to provide companionship to humans. 

God Put It in Us to Care for Animals

By just looking at these two passages of Scripture, we see that God gives the foundation as to why people care for animals. In Genesis 1, God made people stewards of His creatures and in Genesis 2, He brought the animals to Adam so he would not be alone. God called us to rule over animals and made them to live along side us.

No doubt our companionship with animals has been greatly damaged by sin brought on by the fall of mankind, but Scripture does provide a basis for a desire to manage and care for animals. And when we look at passages like Romans 8:20-23 and Isaiah 11:6 we see our relationship with animals will be restored.

If we were created for relationship with animals and someday that relationship will be restored it would make sense that the desire for relationship with animals still lives in us today.

Now, go give your dog (or cat) a hug. You know you want to.

(For more information on conservation and worldview, check out this article by John Stonestreet on Breakpoint.)

Pasquale Mingarelli is a longtime professional photographer and photography instructor. He speaks on creation through the eyes of a photographer and runs The Visual Bible Verse of the Day website. On that website, you can download his PDF 15 Ways to experience God in the Outdoors.

Meet Steve

Meet Steve

Hi, I’m Steve, an author, speaker, and Bible teacher with a heart for exploring God’s Word and God’s world.

I’m interested in the surprising connection between creation, theology, business, and storytelling. We explore those themes and more on this blog.

Be sure to browse the site for faith-affirming articles, book reviews, and podcasts!

The Podcast

The Podcast